I recently received an email from my friend John Campea, whose podcast I participate in on a weekly basis, asking me to submit to him my top ten favourite super hero movies of all time. Personally, I hate making lists like this, because I’m always afraid that I’ve left something out that deserves consideration, and also because I feel that my tastes change depending upon my mood at the time. So officially, this list should be called Darren’s Top Ten Superhero Movies of All Time as of approx 8am on Wednesday July 5, 2006.
Please note that I have not yet seen the recently released Superman Returns, and it could very well make it into my top ten after being viewed. Like I said, this is my list as of right now.
Number 10: Spiderman 2
All of the great things about the first movie (interesting characters, compelling story, etc.), but with better special effects, a far more interesting villain, and kick-asser action sequences. It made many a young boy wish that they too could shoot adhesive webbing from somewhere in their wrist area (which seems rather strange to me, since spiders don’t have wrists – Shouldn’t Tobey Maguire be shooting webs from his anus?)
Number 9: Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow
Some may dispute that this be included in a list of superhero movies, since the Sky Captain himself doesn’t have any actual powers. To argue that point, I’d point out that neither does Batman. In every other way Sky Captain is a superhero movie – over-the-top villains, crazy futuristic technology, and acts of death-defying heroism. This movie had a completely unique feel, and showed how much you can do when all of your sets are a green-screen. Bonus points for having two strong, beautiful women who are never forced into the “damsels in distress” role, and armies of giant robots.
Number 8: Unbreakable
The second major release from M. Night Shyamalan, and a masterpiece of directing, in my opinion. With its slow pace and atmospheric visuals, Shyamalan shows that a superhero movie does not have to be non-stop explosions caused by high-tech villains in order to be compelling. The hero is a blue-collar security guard. The villain cannot adequately navigate a staircase to the subway without causing himself serious injury. The plot is secondary to the characters (as is the case in all of Shyamalan’s movies), and the characters are interesting enough to make the “twist” seem incidental or unnecessary. More a movie about “super heroism” itself than anything else.
Number 7: Powerpuff Girls The Movie
Yeah, I know I’m going to get razzed for this one, but honestly, there’s nothing like watching three kindergarten girls with superpowers violently kicking the living crap out of every villain who gets in their way. The perfect combination of cute cartoony-ness, vertigo-inducing action, and smarter-than-a-kids-movie-should-be writing. Don’t let its supposed girliness deter you. You can watch this movie, enjoy it, and still retain your manliness. Unless, of course, you’re a woman.
Number 6: The Incredibles
What can I say about this movie that has not been said already? Fun for all ages, and more intelligently written than 95% of what comes out of Hollywood today. Some deep themes and lessons, even (and almost especially) for adults. If you don’t like it, you’re stupid. And if you haven’t seen it, well for heaven’s sake get your sheltered hindquarters to your local DVD vender and watch it! Before people think you’re stupid.
Number 5: X-men (the first one)
The movie that revitalized the superhero-movie genre after the Batman sequels killed it. A wonderful adaptation of the comics that I used to avidly collect, and surprisingly non-cheesy. Not only an interesting piece of action and adventure, but a subtle message about diversity and tolerance as well. I am astounded that everyone thinks X-men 2 was so amazing – I personally found it choppy, uneven, and forgettable. But this first movie was focused and compelling. Made me want to grow Wolverine claws something bad, although I don’t realistically know what I would do with them. Ice sculpting maybe?
Number 4: Hellboy
I loved the premise of this movie when I first heard about it, and the execution of it was amazing to see. Clearly a movie made by a writer and director who was in love with the source material. The villains were incredible (a clockwork corpse-ninja? Come on!), and every scene that involved Selma Blair bursting into flame gave me that rush that you can usually only get from kicking the winning soccer goal while listening to classic Christian Metal. One “hell” of a great flick.
Number 3: Mystery Men
I can’t remember how many times I’ve quoted this movie with my friends. So many hilarious lines, and so many amazingly funny performances by the cast. Hank Azaria, Greg Kinnear, William H. Macy, and Geoffrey Rush are all in top-form, and Ben Stiller, Janeane Garofalo, and Paul Reubens have never been better. A perfect parody of the superhero genre, and a cast of endearing characters that actually makes you want to see a sequel (which, ironically, they never made). It may not be high-budget, but what it lacks in fancy effects, it more than makes up for in fun.
Number 2: Blade 2
A perfect action movie from start to finish. Every fight sequence is beautifully constructed, and every vampire death is fun to watch. The premise is engaging, the characters are interesting, the villains are wonderfully evil and grotesque, and there’s even some heartfelt emotion thrown in. I love how vampire society is further fleshed-out, and how vampirism is viewed through a scientific, and not just a mystical, portrayal. Genetically manipulated vampires. How cool is that?! Anytime I want to see a movie that’s pure “slice up the bad guys with attitude and style” fun, this is the first DVD that comes off my shelf.
Number 1: Batman Begins
More than just a movie about a hero’s origins. More than just a villain getting what’s coming to him. More than fancy effects and over-the-top fight sequences. This is a superhero movie that’s actually about something – a few things, in fact. It’s a movie about the nature of fear, and how fear can be used to weaken or strengthen us. It’s a movie about revenge, and discovering the limits that you’ll go to in exacting that revenge on someone else. It’s about justice, and how far one can go beyond society’s limitations in seeing justice served. The first comic-book-based superhero movie that’s truly intelligent, and if we’re lucky, it won’t be the last.
So there you have it – my list, for what it’s worth. I hope you’ve had as much fun reading it as I have had in writing it. Which is just one fun-notch above finding a quarter, but one notch below eating the last bowl of the sugar cereal.